FAQ   Register    Log in

Pittbull or Australian Cattle Dog?

	Home -> Discussion -> Exercise Buddy

Author Message Duke-med Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:21 am    Post subject: Pittbull or Australian Cattle Dog? i would like to either get a Australian Cattle Dog or american pittbull terrier. The dog would mainly be inside with a medium sized fenced yard out back. Im a junior in college soo i share the house with 3 other people. and 2 husky mixes and a rednose pitt. But sadly none of these dogs are mine so i cant take them with me alot. I would like to either get 1 from a breeder or a rescue if the dog is under a year. The dog would be thoroughly socialized and trained.It would also 1-2 hours are hard exercises a day. Ive also grown up with akitas and bull mastiff soo i know how to handle big strong willed breeds.And i have nothing against labs and goldens i just like these breeds better. I would also not be getting the dog as a guard dog, he would just be my friend and hiking buddy. So with that being said i would like to get yours opinions about which breed is best. And real reasons would be more appreciated the just 1 word answers.thnks Back to top Responsible pug breeder Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:25 am    Post subject: Get a aussie they are better dogs then PITS Back to top Yo LO! LaLaLaLaLa Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:26 am    Post subject: Given the other dogs in the house, I would get another Pit. Australian Cattle Dogs are Working Dogs and I think you'll find the rest of the pack being herded into the corner by one.Edit - Please note that I own 2 Australian Shepherds myself. For those that don't seem to know the difference, a "Aussie" refers to a Australian Shepherd - Australian Cattle Dog is different, Queensland Heeler or Blue Heeler are variations. Back to top Rae Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:28 am    Post subject: pitbull. loyal, easy to train, likes to please owners. loves owners company. great family dog. Back to top Dom Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:29 am    Post subject: Man, pitbulls are ppppppllllllaaaaayyyyyyeeeeddddd out!!! Back to top missmojo78 Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:30 am    Post subject: Although I do like both dogs and you sound like you are more qualified than most pit owners are, I would still go with the Aussie. They are so smart and so much fun. We have an Aussie/Wire Hair Terrier mix and she is the smartest most obedient dog I have ever had. Now in the summer when we are on our patio we can leave the door open and our inside cats don't get out. Our dog's job is to herd them back in when they try to get out (we live by a highway so it is best for the cats). She never harms the cats, love people and other dogs. I would highly recommend an Aussie. Plus, if you are looking to keep renting after college, a lot of places won't except pits. Sad, but too many irresponsible pit owners have ruined it for others. Good luck!Oh but check how the Aussie is with biting, some can be nippy. Back to top KoAussie Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:31 am    Post subject: Both breeds, the American Pit Bull Terrier and the Australian Cattle Dog are high energy breeds that require a lot of exercise and special care for training to make them well mannered members of the household so it is good that you are familiar with hard headed, high drive breeds. My recommendation is to rescue a Pitbull Terrier, if for no other reason than the fact that there are more Pits and Pit mixes in need of rescue than almost any other breed. Saving a life is always a worthy endeavor.*******"Aussies" are Australian SHEPHERDS and sometimes a nick name given to Australian Terriers, but not to Australian Cattle Dogs. Back to top Vi Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:32 am    Post subject: some pitts are outlawed in some states and are very aggressive, i suggest a australian cattle dog just to be safe. Back to top mckrav13 Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:33 am    Post subject: Get an Austrailian shepard! They are better thsn both. Pitbulls are fighting dogs, and Cattle Dogs are working dogs. Back to top 27PurpleRoses Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:35 am    Post subject: I would recommend researching the breeds to learn their traits and what they were originally bred for before you make a purchase. There are a whole lot of breeds that are good for companionship, not just pits, but American Bulldogs - English Bulldogs, Pugs, and a lot more including the Bull Mastiffs! Each have their own traits and of course, personalities!The Australian Cattle Dog is probably a herder type dog which means it may chase after cars and bicyclists -- something to consider since you want this dog to live where you wind up moving to. Also if you want a family later, you may want a dog that is not a one-man dog and will accept children in your life. So research a little more and choose a wonderful companion for yourself.You sound like a very good person to own a dog and that means you will take good care of it, so any dog you choose will be blessed to live with you. Back to top just an opinion Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:35 am    Post subject: In my honest opinion, I would choose the Australian Cattle Dog. Not because I think they are necessarily any better than a Pitt, but, in many cities there are very strict regulations about what dog breeds are allowed, and most animal shelters (at least in my area) won't even adopt out Pitt Bull Terriers, and those that are captured by animal control must be ID'ed by pictures or other 100%-provable forms of ownership before they will be given back to their owners (the idea behind this is that any Joe Blow off the street can walk in, say they lost a Pitt Bull, and pick one out and use it for fighting). From what I understand Pitt Bulls are wonderful dogs, but given the difficulties that can be encountered owning them (and you may not know right now every place you will live for the next 12-15 years of the dog's life), I personally would not have one. I must say I agree with you that Labradors and Goldens are great dogs but that they're not for everyone. I have a Brittany that I just love, and wouldn't trade him for any other breed. So long as you love the breed you choose, you can provide it the time, training, mental stimulation, and exercise it needs, and you are going to be a responsible pet owner (vaccinations, spaying/neutering of pet-quality dogs, high quality food, etc.) then the breed you choose is entirely acceptable. Whatever you choose, I hope you enjoy it! Back to top poobah Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:38 am    Post subject: Cattle dogs, like all herders need a lot, and I mean a lot of exercise. They like to run, especially with other dogs. They want to herd them and people too. If they don't get enough exercise they will get crazy in the house. Having said that, they are among the smartest dogs in the world as are Border Collies and other herders. Also, females are easier to train than males and usually (but not always) get along better in dog society. Back to top Metro_Station Lover Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:48 am    Post subject: I would get an australian cattle dog those are great active buddys you can have and love to hike! They are great dogs but pitbulls are great dogs too you should pick! Back to top Lisa R Yahoo User Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2008 11:55 am    Post subject: Aussies are more respected based on the reputations pits have gotten. You'll know the right dog when you see it, but keep in mind, being a college student with others...may already give the wrong impression. Think about your neighbors, how would they feel with a pit? Also, Aussies need LOTS of attention and playtime. Some states/cities require extra insurance on bully breeds..can you afford that? Back to top

	Discussion -> Exercise Buddy	All times are GMT - 8 Hours
Page 1 of 1

Source:     Powered by Yahoo! Answers